| 2022: | 1B Tate Abbott, RHP Michael Allen, RHP Cole Bates, C Jeremiah Boyd, SS Chase Bruno, OF Hunter Cole, 3B Alden Cottle, OF Jackson Hipp, RHP Jacob Lawler, RHP Chris Morris, OF Nate Paulsen, RHP Gage Riddick, 2B Bryce Stephens, DH Tanner Thach, LHP Nicky Wohleking
Jeremiah Boyd won PCL Home Run Derby |
| 2021: | RHP Cole Bates, 2B Chase Bruno, OF Hunter Cole, RHP Jared Davis, RHP Blake Gipson, 2B Casey Haire, OF Joe Haney, C Case Kermode, 1B Josh Pernetti, RHP Daniel Willie
Josh Pernetti won PCL Home Run Derby |
| 2020: | OF Alan Alonso, C Allen Brown, INF Shane Easter, RHP Brett Fulk, INF Casey Haire, RHP Colin Kriminger, RHP Ryan Kutz, RHP Daly Marcano, LHP Jake Rice, RHP Alex Shirazi, DH/LHP Josiah Sightler, RHP Ray Stocum, OF Houston Wright, Head Coach Marshall McDonald |
| 2019: | OF Alex Alders, LHP Jack Eisenbarger, OF Qunicy Hamilton, LHP Alex Theis, IF Ian Walters, Head Coach Russ Burroughs |
| 2018: | 3B Rich Cuifo, OF Devon Gardner, RHP Charles Hall, 1B Zane Harris, RHP Jake Miller |
| 2017: | C Jason Agresti, OF James Battley, OF Jamie Galazin, LHP Carmen Giampetruzzi, IF Connor Kopach, OF Billy Wilson |
| 2016: | RHP Perry DellaValle, 2B Trey Hair, OF Richie Cunningham, DH/UTL Bobby Schuman, Head Coach Bryan Hill, Assistant Coach John Hunter |
| 2015: | RHP Zach Prendergast, RHP David Bednar, RHP Dylan Zarosky, SS Evan Rogers, OF Demetre Taylor, 2B Chad Sedio, C Chance Shepard
David Bednar named CPL Defensive Player of the All-Star Game |
| 2014: | RHP Josh Roeder, LHP Gunnar Kines, SS Evan Rogers, OF Orlando Olivera, 2B Ryan Raslowsky, Head Coach Bryan Hill
Josh Roeder named CPL Defensive Player of the All-Star Game |
| 2013: | 2B/OF Nick Thompson, P/1B Nick Miller, P Jake McCoy, P Connor Cuff, OF/1B Trent Miller, 3B Josh Hampton, C Jacob Reese, DH Adam Kirsch, Head Coach Bryan Hill
Adam Kirsch won CPL Home Run Derby |
| 2012: | 1B Spencer Branigan, P Jordan Egan, OF Michael Camporeale, P Matt Duncan, OF Jason Kanzler, 2B Koby Kraemer, Head Coach Steve Moritz |
| 2011: | 2B Joey Wendle, P Jordan Egan, OF Ryan Brenner, P Brooks Fiala, OF/IF Brian Blasik, P Joshua Branstetter, Head Coach Dirk Kinney |
| 2010: | P Mark Montgomery, OF Brian Billigen, P Coty Saranthus, 1B Jake Magner, OF Billy Burns, SS AJ Rusbarsky, 2B Neiko Johnson,
Mark Montgomery named CPL Defensive Player of the All-Star Game |
| 2009: | IF Gerard Hall, OF Adam De La Garza, 1B Jake Magner, OF Billy Swanson, P Anthony Markham
IF Gerard Hall named CPL Offensive Player of the All-Star Game |
| 2008: | C Ty Boyles, 1B/OF Doug Kroll, OF Brett Nommensen, P Joe Key, P Luke Demko |
| 2007: | IF Brian Conley, C Will Greenberg, SS Tony Kostelnik, OF Kevin Mattison, OF Nick Nosti, P JP Primus |
| 2006: | C Bucky Strickland, 1B Brendon Hitchcock, OF Derek Kennamer, P Jeff Fischer |
| 2005: | OF Kevin Reynolds, IF/OF Skyler Stromsmoe, P Brad Stone, IF Steve Maiolo
OF Kevin Reynolds named CPL Offensive Player of the All-Star Game |
| 2004: | SS Ryan Khoury, OF Jason Hurst, P Danny Powers, P Chris Cahill, P Daniel Gemma, P Weston Curles, P Pete Henyan, Head Coach Joel Tremblay
OF Jason Hurst named CPL Offensive Player of the All-Star Game |
| 2003: | 1B/3B Nick Shimer |
| 2002: | 2B Bilal Omar, 2B/SS Colin Cronin, C Thomas Berkery, OF Kyle Pope, P Mike Urvalek |
| 2001: | OF Daniel Vick, P Blake Horsman |
| 2000: | C Dwayne Smith, IF/OF Sean Ferrell |
| 1999: | OF Adam Swann, SS Bryon Jeffcoat, 1B Brandon Blair, OF Kevin Hairr, P Chris Spigner |
ONSL 
