Tidewater Summer League Most Valuable Player
2020: Houston Wright, University of Tennessee – Martin
Coastal Plain League Accolades (The Edenton Steamers were in the CPL from 1998-2019)
CPL Petitt Cup Playoff Championship
2004: Champions
2005: Champions
2010: Runner-Up
2011: Runner-Up
2015: Champions (Also named the 2015 Perfect Game Summer Collegiate Team of the Year)
2015 Petitt Cup Champions
CPL Coach of the Year Winners
2004: Joel Tremblay, Wayne State College (NE)
2011: Dirk Kinney
2012: Steve Moritz
2013: Bryan Hill, Chowan University (NC)
2015: Bryan Hill, Chowan University (NC)
CPL Hitter of the Year Winners
2012: Michael Camporeale, University of Washington
2015: Chad Sedio, Miami University (OH)
CPL Pitcher of the Year Winners
2010: Coty Saranthus, Delta State University (MS)
2015: Zach Prendergast, Seton Hall University (NJ)
CPL Broadcaster of the Year Winners
2012: Danny Angel
2013: Danny Angel
2016: Chris Lehman
2018: PJ Potter
2019: Victoria Conway
ONSL 
